On 25 April 2019, Ponce opened the score as Marko Livaja’s deflected effort struck the right post, but the prolific Argentinian striker was on hand to lash the ensuing rebound into the net in a hammering 4–0 Greek Cup away semi-final second-leg game against Lamia, and for the third consecutive season, AEK met PAOK in the Greek Cup final, whom they beat 3–0, in an ambiguous win.