Clinton Heylin ( Revolution in the Air: The Songs of Bob Dylan, Vol. 1: 1957–73) is skeptical, saying that Helstrom "laid it on thick" for Thompson, but cites evidence on both sides of the question (Heylin acknowledges that Dylan did introduce "Girl From the North Country" at a 1978 show with "First girl I ever loved is in the house tonight, I wrote a song about her..." when Helstrom was apparently indeed in attendance, but also provides some contrary indicators), while Robert Shelton (No Direction Home: The Life and Music of Bob Dylan), favors Bonnie Beecher as the Girl.